This year’s Emmy Awards conveyed the reunion that everyone wanted by nobody knew they required. The stars of Nickelodeon’s Kenan and Kel and the 1997 film Great Burger took the stage together in a surprise segment during the Emmys, bringing delight to the hearts of each and every millennial watching the broadcast. Of course, we’re talking about Kenan Thompson and Kel Mitchell, who first made magic together on All That nearly 30 years ago.

Thompson, a Saturday Night Live mainstay, hosted this year’s Emmy Awards. During the show, Thompson took part in a sketch that featured Kumail Nanjiani and Jason Sudeikis, where Nanjiani acted as an inexperienced bartender. After Sudeikis walked away, Thompson told Nanjiani to serve a man who was sitting with his head on the bar. The man raised his head and revealed himself to be Kel Mitchell, and those in attendance rooted for the Kenan and Kel reunion.

Yet again in addition to those in the audience, the people watching at home freaked out over seeing Thompson and Mitchell back together on TV.

You can look at some of the reactions from fans on Twitter underneath!